Hey Cry-Tom, this is a reply I had made to the the other big thread about this issue:
I basically got told by the restore page that I was logged in and my username is gamesas. That is obviously incorrect.

I had initially created this account with this name and my email address back in the open beta. I was never able to log in through the game, though I was able to log in through the site. Note, the same email and name here are mine on Gamespy from an account there made ages ago.
Around 4 days ago I tried the delete account option in the hopes I could start over, but that left me with a functioning forum account and no ability to reregister with my username and email.
Hope this helps you diagnose whatever's gone awry with this. Let em know by PM if you need any additional information.