unaffected? and everyone on Vvardenfell died unless they had a means of teleportation. You must realize that it isn't like Vvardenfell was Nuked, it could be more accurate to say Vvardenfell was the Nuke. Northern Morrowind and southern Morrowind (basically only what is straight below Vvardenfell due to powerful southern prevailing winds) was completely destroyed by Lava, poisons gases, rock, tsunamis, and basically Mehrunes Dagon in general (his sphere ISN'T destruction, it is Destruction THROUGH nature.) Then the Argonians attacked to massacre the already VERY weak Dunmer.
I'll go through this point-by-point, because I find it easier that way.
You must realize that it isn't like Vvardenfell was Nuked, it could be more accurate to say Vvardenfell was the Nuke.
Not exactly. The sequence of events goes like this:
1. MoT falls from sky, destroys Vivec and probably a large part of the surrounding area.
My comment: This is the "nuke." Very few people probably survived this. As I brought up in my last post, people in real life have survived a nuclear explosion, some even survived BOTH nukes in Japan during WWII, so I don't think it's implausible to assume that some would have survived the falling of the MoT. Yes, i'm aware that this is a universe in which magic exists and it's not EXACTLY like real life, but I think some real life parallels can be used, even in a game world.
2. The MoT crashing into the earth sets off the volcano at Red Mountain.
My comment: Volcanic eruptions are very different from nuclear explosions. The destruction is a lot slower; lava takes time to travel to downhill and into the surrouding countryside, and Vvardenfell is a BIG island. Add to that that the representation we see in the games we play is scaled down, and the lava would probably take days to completely cover the island. Those immediately around the volcano would probaby die very quickly, but that area was already a wasteland to begin with, so I don't see a huge loss of life initially after the eruption. I'll get more into this in the next paragraph.
Basically, to say that Vvardenfell itself was the nuke is, in my opinion, inaccurate. The MoT was the nuke, and the eruption was a by-product of the nuke being launched.
Northern Morrowind and southern Morrowind (basically only what is straight below Vvardenfell due to powerful southern prevailing winds) was completely destroyed by Lava, poisons gases, rock, tsunamis,and basically Mehrunes Dagon in general (his sphere ISN'T destruction, it is Destruction THROUGH nature.)
I actually had to look this up in the book to make sure what I was about to say next was correct. To quote the book:
"But what happend?"
Sul was silent for so long this time that Attrebus thought he wouldn't speak again, but he finally sighed.
"The ingenium exploded. It hurled Vuhon into Oblivion. Then the ministry crashed into the city, and Vvardenfell exploded."
Sul trudged to the other side of the island, trying not to let his rage blot out his ability to think. It wasn't enough that the ministry fell; the impact caused the volcano that was the heart and namesake of Vvardenfell to explode. Ash, lava, and tidal waves had done their work, adn when that was calmed, the Argonians had come, eager to repay what survived of his people for millennia of abuse and enslavement.
Of course, those that had settled in southern Morrowind were likely regretting it now, as Umbriel moved over their villages.
Now, based on these quotes we can pretty fairly assume two things:
1. Vvardenfell was destroyed by the combination of the MoT's crash and the volcanic eruption that followed.
2. Southern Morrowind was not affected by these things, but was invaded Argonians soon after these events (though I don't think it would have been IMMEDIATELY afterward).
Even if we go with your assumption that
part of Southern Vvardenfell was affected by the MoT and Eruption due to "powerful southern prevailing winds," (an assumption I find doubtful as Vvardenfell and the mainland are separated by quite a bit of water), the book mentions nothing about "powerful southern prevailing winds." Now, i'll grant you that while the wind might not have been
literally poisonous, it still wouldn't be very friendly to breathe and probably would have caused some deaths among the populace. But again, just like how lava travels in it's own way, so does wind, and we don't know which way it was blowing at the time. It might have blown north, south, east, west, or maybe even not at all. The direction it traveled would have directly affected the damage it did.
I think it is safe to say, though, that the wind wasn't traveling in all directions at once. So, I think it is also fair to say that not ALL of the Dunmer on Vvardenfell would have fallen victim to these "poisonous" winds. Some would have died, yes, but others would have survived long enough to escape either via teleportation (which I assume you mean primarily Mark and Recall) or by other means (boats, silt strider, Mages Guild Guide, etc.) and get the word out to others that "the wind and/or lava is traveling in 'X' direction!" thus causing others to escape, as well. I don't think it's too much of a stretch to say that a lot of Dunmer would have escaped the winds and lava due to either them not being in it's immediate path/direction or by them hearing word of it quick enough.
The book also mentioned tidal waves. This would have taken many lives, for sure, but I think it's fair to say that they only affected the coastal towns and maybe a little further inland (say, as far inland as Balmora, since that is relatively close to Hla Oad). I find it highly unlikely that a huge massive tide wave (or waves) completely covered the entire island.
Then the Argonians attacked to massacre the already VERY weak Dunmer.
Southern Morrowind has a large population of Dunmer; probably much larger than Vvardenfell, though admittedly I don't have a source to back that up. However, to call the Dunmer "weak" I think gives them too little credit; broken and battered they may have been, but I like to think they still had SOME fight left in them.
So, when the Argonians came to exact their revenge, I imagine that the Dunmer fought back with all they had; enough to let some people escape. I agree that it was probably a massacre (Sul alludes to as much in the quote I posted), but I don't think they would have killed ALL of the Dunmer; some, if not many, probably escaped. Unlike a natural disaster (in which there can be little-to-no warning beforehand), a war is neither instantaneous nor all-consuming. People survive wars, both during and after it. Otherwise, we wouldn't have any living WWII vets, or vets of any other war, for that matter. Plus, the Argonians would have come through Black Marsh, so those Dunmer who lived farther north of there would have had time to escape before the Argonian invasion arrived.
So, while a large number of Dunmer probably died by Argonian hands, I doubt ALL of them did. And unless the Argonians are completely heartless, i'm sure that they would have spared many women and children (though again, I have no source to back this up). And even if they didn't, I think my point still stands that there were likely more than a few survivors.
There, that is my objective anolysis on the issue. I'd like to say that I didn't intend any of this to come off as angry or self-righteous; I am just trying to present my case in a logical, objective manner by giving my thoughts and providing supporting facts to my argument. I hope you are not offended.