» Sat Nov 06, 2010 5:30 pm
Either the orginal post was sarcasm, or the OP has had a rather sheltered educational experience.
The public school system in many states, and in the majority of the United States is woefully underfunded, underdisciplined, and is the victom of conflicting politcal diatribe.
My state comes in at the bottom for funding, is going to experience severe budget cuts. Music, art, physical education, after school tutoring, severe learning disability, emotioinal and mentally hadicapped, and mentoring programs, plus outreach programs for at risk youth have all been cut. It seems adminstrative positions never get the axe.
However, teh governor is slashing taxes for big business. Same [censored], different politican .
My children attend private, and I tutor at a private school. Public school here is atrocius, students graduating from the public school system here are ending up taking remedial classes in college just to level up to the starting point. Plus, the graduation rate is low.
I was disciplined with corporal punishment in seventh grade for being in the wrong place at the wrong time with the wrong people, caught between warring cliques. I was accused of smoking and skipping PE. I had a clean school record, and opted for three swats. They were hard swats, but I didn't flinch. Or cry. Because you see, if my father had found out, he would have beaten the holy living [censored] out of me.
Lesson learned?
I figured hmmmmm, next time dramalamas happen, I am staying the hell out of it, and I am going to be more discerning in choosing friends.
Corporal punishment doesn't work for all students, some don't respond well to painful stimuli. Some don't respond well to time out. Some could give a fat rat's ass that they are going to be suspended. Discipline does not mean resorting to physical violence. It means consistency in dealing with substandard behavior. Which is why I am a fan of in school suspension, isolation, and for repeat offenders, expulsion. This is the ace in the hole private schools hold over public. Teachers have more than enough to do between lesson planning, teaching, grading, recording data, and ongoing training. Students are NOT the font of knowledge, they are there to be taught. If they can't shut up, respect the person teaching them, and not distract the class, then those students have no business in a mainstream classroom.
Private schools can pick and choose who they want to teach, screw up, and you are out. Public schools are required by law to offer education regardless of physical. emotional, or mental handicap.