Are you sure? Did you calculate your armorrating? ( http://www.uesp.net/wiki/Skyrim:Armor )
As far as i know, it is still bugged and work with all armor. The "Blacksmithing increases 15% faster" is also not fixed and give a steady 15 (hidden) points to smithing instead of a faster skill increase.
That's my understanding (and experience) too. I think their confusion comes from not noticing a diff between heavy and light armor (or types), which is precisely what you'd expect due to the bug giving the bonus to all armor types. (Personally, I kind of like the bug as it makes the quest useful to every armor-wearing character build.)