But... I really, really dislike Boone. On my latest playthrough, I thought I'd give him another chance, but... no. Instead I abandoned him at the top of Black Mountain, and promptly took Raul instead.
I think what it is, it's that he seems to have all the worst traits of so-called "cool" characters. For example!
1. He's overpowered. He'll 1-shot kill things before you even SEE them. And with the slow-motion killcam, this is pretty annoying! Plus, a sniper? The guy's a 13-year old Halo fan's dream come true.
2. He's a dark, tortured soul. The dude is frickin' Lestat. Or, like, Edward Cullen. "Oh noes! Woe is me! I had to kill my own wife instead of rescuing her! Life is hard! LOVE MEEEE!"
3. To top it all off, he's got an awful, stereotypical "badass" voice. All gravelly and harsh. He shoulda been a ghoul with a voice like that. I get it, he's trying to be all tough, but he just comes off as obnoxious.
Frankly, he would've been more interesting if he was a raging Jet-head. Gravelly voice and not sleeping? Yeeeah, you're not THAT traumatised.