Holy crap, someone with actual weapon experience! Finally! I always did think the way it was held was a bit peculiar.
That being said, I love it as if it were my child.
What's peculiar is the way they've done the reloading animation. To reload a henry, one must use a finger (preferrably the thumb) to push the magazine follower thumb latch (which when your weapon is empty of cartridges will be at the very rear of the magazine tube right up against the front of the reciever sticking down just a touch from the bottom of the mag tube, http://www.ahffirearms.com/products/henrylincoln.asp?) all the way up the magazine tube, thereby compressing the magazine tube spring up into the rotating magazine tube end cap (which also has the front sight on it. What idiot thought of that?) Once the mag spring is compressed inside the rotating end cap, you pivot or rotate said end cap to the side which completely captures the mag follower and spring and holds them at bay so you have free access to the mag tube. You then load your bulllitz one at a time, base first into the mag tube and once done, you pivot the end cap back over the mag tube and allow the mag spring to extend and compress the follower and all the cartridges down the tube so they may feed into the action when needed.
This all takes a considerably longer time than we see in the reloading animation, which consists of only the steps where you pivot the end cap and then the player *shakes* a handfull of cartridges down the mag tube, ala loading a handfull of BB's style, and pivots the cap closed again.
Of course this reloading was blazing fast for the time it was developed, a real game changer in combat, but by today's standards, it's slow as hell. Who wants to be sitting there dropping .44 cartridges down the tube one by one when that SM is about to whack yo on the head with a nailboard. I understand the reasoning behind speeding the reload ainimation to point where it's not an undue burden to the player, but I also feel they should have gone for the more realistic approach. What would you do when your rifle is out of ammo and the nailboard is aswingin' at you? You'd switch to your sidearm and take down the target, that's what you'd do. Not sit there and try to reload your henry in close combat.
-Gunny out.