The annoying thing is that these fans don't take into account that these negatives are made up for by positives. From what I know fans have always wanted smithing to customise their armour and yet they just ignore this and quite frankly whine about how the series has been butchered since Morrowind. I never thought it that amazing to run around in mismatched armour and if this a deal breaker to any of you then fine but your the ones missing out.
I am still buying Skyrim and I think the ones who say they aren't are lying unless they really hated Oblivion.
If greaves being out were the only thing, I wouldnt care (much).
But its: Some skills and spell effects, spellmaking, attributes, classes, birthsigns, armour slots, and not removing quest and map markers.
And how knows what else that I cant remember right now.
A whole lot of removal. And at a certain point its just too much.
And yeah, Oblivion was a rather horrible game only made playable by the extensive modding community.