I've grown tired of warcraft. What once used to be fast paced gameplay where you were kept on your toes has been replaced with 5 second fights, and allowing players to respec before each match to be set up to counter other players. But it remains as the only game with the PVPrs dream of the 1+2 punch combo of some of the smoothest controls (no hicups, never feel sluggish) in the MMO industry, and 2v2,3v3, & 5v5 arenas. This makes for some fast faced on your toes gameplay. It's exciting. kept me playing for nearly 7 years.
When I first played the beta of The Elder Scrolls Online I was excited. This game has managed to match the level of smoothness you find when controlling your character in WoW. Few games have met that standard that I myself (as well as many in the online gaming community) have come to expect in our MMOs. Even more so in some areas, feels as if it had been surpassed.
When I saw all the skill lines, and that you could only pick 5+1 ulti at a time, I saw massive potential for 2v2 /3v3/4v4/5v5 type gameplay. The kind that had the potential to pick up the millions of arena only PVPr's who are clinging to WoW simply because it "is the only one" with an arena system. I thought, this is going to be the game I get into for the next decade.
And then it happened. Developer interview stating they wouldn't be having arena or small scale instanced battlegrounds, that ESO would be exclusively World PVP. My stomache sank. I canceled my WoW a few months ago in anticipation of this game. I never pre order games for exactly this reason. I was taught never to count your chickens before they hatch.
In world pvp, you die, resurrect at the spawn, then spend 2-3 minutes running trying to find an enemy. You most likely either out number whoever you find, meaning it's not very engaging or exciting, or the oposite is true and the enemy out numbers you, meaning instant death. This means you get a few seconds of disengaging player on player combat, with loads of running. Just doesn't hold the interest.
Arenas are burst of combat that last for several minutes at a time, sometimes 10-20 minutes. It's intense. You're on the edge of your seat the entire time. Especially so in the longer matches, where it's clear that it's anyones game, and that one slip up on your part could spell defeat. You don't get that type of gameplay in World PvP. Not to mention World PvP eventually dwindles to nothing as players become bored, but arena players will que up and play, week after week, year after year.
Look at twitch streams. People are willing to watch LoL matches and WoW arena. Where are the streams for GW2 World PvP? Answer is there are none. World PvP only holds the attention span of the person playing it for so long, where as Arena style pvp is captivating enough to draw spectation. I myself, will be taking a pass on ESO, as well as putting online gaming in general on hiatus for a while. That being said If an arena (or even 10-20 man battleground) system was announced, I would buy this game in a heartbeat. But as it is, I see nothing for me as a longtime hardcoe arena style player.
P.S. A damn shame that the first online venture for a franchise in which the original title was literally named "Arena" isn't going to have an Arena.