I've completed the other two parts of the quest for Pelagius III with Sheogorath... but I am utterly stuck on the atronach thrall battle. I got that I can use Wabbajack to switch the atro's form... but as soon as I get my atro to a form that is strong against his, he just immediately changes it to one strong against mine! I have made no progress at all in it, I'm just repeatedly wabba-ing my atro to no effect.


EDIT: Nevermind, I took a step outside the box and wabba'd the two guards on the other side with Pelly.

This stumped me for a good 15 minutes as well until I got really bored and looked across the fighting pit (veiled hint).

Hint #1: Do what bored players do best with a crazy and powerful staff.

Hint #2: It has nothing to do with the fighting atronachs.

I'm assuming this is the part where you're standing at an arena with two atronachs fighting down below and 3 people sitting across from you also viewing the battle. I just targeted one of the guys across from me and used Wabbajack on them, causing the other two guards to attack the wabbajack'd person.

I too was having a problem with that. I thought it was funny how Sheogorath says "I thought you'd never figure it out!" when you finally do.

Now that the quest is done... do I need Pelly's pelvis for anything, or can I toss it?