» Sun May 16, 2010 6:30 pm
Okay, I'm going to agree with the claim that it doesn't translate letter-for-letter. Here's my argument.
We have the form: EB and BE. The only thing I can find that matches that form in standard English is ON and NO.
However, we also have the form ECG. "G" occurs 32 times (it is the most letter-- the next one is only 23 times), so we can assume that it is really "e". This takes care of combinations such as "HG", et cetera.
If this is the case, we are left with either o_e or n_e. We cannot use "n", because it's different in the cipher-- it is either E or B, but we need C.
Is there any word in common English, spelled o_e or n_e, aside from "one" (which it can't be, as I explained)?
oae
obe
oce
ode
ofe
oge
ohe
oie
oje
oke
ole
ome
one
ooe
ope
oqe
ore
ose
ote
oue
ove
owe
oxe
oye
oze
nae
nbe
nce
nde
nfe
nge
nhe
nie
nje
nke
nle
nme
noe
nne
npe
nqe
nre
nse
nte
nue
nve
nwe
nxe
nye
nze
What are we left with as possibilities? I see "ore" and "owe".
If we go with "owe", we are stuck with the form "CBENI"-- that would make it wn___. However, if we go with "ore", we are stuck with rn___. Neither work.
My conclusion? It's not a straight cipher.
If I'm missing something, please let me know. thanks.