Well, if you want popular opinion, why not search the Nexus, and sort accordingly? Plus, check the Top 100, naturally.
For example, with http://www.tesnexus.com/downloads/advancedsearch.php you can find just about anything.
You can enter search terms (note: partial words do match, generally), http://tesnexus.com/downloads/search.php?name=rose&scid=20&author=&mname=&desc=&size1=&size2=&downloads1=&downloads2=&udate1_day=&udate1_month=&udate1_year=&udate2_day=&udate2_month=&udate2_year=&ldate1_day=&ldate1_month=&ldate1_year=&ldate2_day=&ldate2_month=&ldate2_year=&endorsemants=&images=&readme=&advltonly=&opensource=&page=1&orderby=downloads&order=DESC. That's a search for "rose" (a random thing that popped into my head), sorted by downloads, descending. But you can do whatever, however you like.
And there's the http://www.tesnexus.com/downloads/categories.php option, and within each of those, you can sort as you like as well. You might find downloads descending or endorsemants descending to be the most useful, in this context. Or not - that's for you to discover.
Enjoy.

edit: Basically, what *I* like is unlikely to be relevant to *you*. So, why should I (or most others, I suppose) respond with specific personal likes? I happen to favour realistic/historical/pseudo-historical, followed by plausible and sensible, followed by plausible and beautiful (though these last two can be the same thing, if rarely). Most people... don't.