I played Both of them to Death. Each of their Expansions...I literally pimped out my House of Hlaalu as much as I could untill the Evil stupid Loot Bag showed up. I played Morrowind on PC and on Xbox. I liked Xbox the most, but once I started downloading mods from the community I was on my PC more thanks to Starcraft/Diablo.
Morrowind for me:
Dark Elves-Heavy Armored Magic user. LOVED the Conjuration creatures. Loved enchanting [censored]. I was the Xzibit of Enchanting.
"YO DAWG I HEARD YOU LIKE GUARDING! So WE ENCHANTED YOUR SHIELD WITH SUMMON DREMORA, SO YOU CAN HAVEA GUARD WHILE YOU GUARD!"
The Magic = Better in Morrowind.
Oblivion: Better Ranged, and Better Melee. NO STUPID...."You missed" <----BS. Look...Just because I have a 0 in Spear Skills Doesn't mean I MISSED. I LITERALLY stabbed some guy, and it misses.. Game Mechanics in Morrowind were not as fun as Oblivion.
If they could:
A) Put Morrowind in Oblivion's Game Mechanics and Cities. Seriously, Re-make Morrowind into Oblivion's Game Design. It will sell, and it will be great. Possibly Game of the year.
B) Put Morrowind's SPELLS in Oblivion. I miss Levitate damn it. =/ I used to Levitate all the time. Going Over Red Mountain was fun. NOW the annoying BIRDS...THOSE I could do with out!
C) Put Morrowind's MUSIC in Oblivion. The Musical Score while traveling I could listen to all day...long.
Then Morrowind would be top for me. Like some one else said: Oblivion had better Polish.
You had Mounts, You had Instant Traveling instead of Having to remember every five minutes to put up Mark and Recall. You didn't have to deal with Rats and Crabs beating the [censored] out of you at low levels. <---That was just ridiculous. My Warrior HAD to use a Fireball majority of his begining fights...So I stopped being warrior ish in Morrowind. Which was a HUGE let down. You had So many weapons to choose from, but [censored] if you can't use um, or have to spend alot of money training them. =/
Morrowind to me, WAS the best, Oblivion hit it up a few notches even though where Morrowind had better, Oblivion made it better for me in other modes that...well...Make it top. DLC like Battlethorn castle where it gives you a non-glitched home, helpers, Etcs...like Skingrad's home = epic. Houses in Morrowind...Hlaalu was good, small...but good. You needed the Creator thing for PC to really make that shine.
The One thing I liked about Morrowind was...It really did CATER to Magic Types. I wanted to be a caster in this game. And the Swapping of outfits, Adding Shoulder Pauldrons, I always did the basic Brown Robe with Orcish Spaulders. Pants usually something heavy and enchanted, so was chest piece...but I liked the Robes looks + Spaulders.
---------
To the people being negative saying "Oh the only way people voted oblivion was because they played it first or didn't play morrowind at all", I'm the Exception I guess...or one of few.
I swear to you, I must have wasted most of my highschool in Vvardenfell on Xbox Alone, how much I must have not gone to bed or only had 3 hrs sleep due to building my own ish/looking up mods for PC version...Morrowind PC Creator = Sims 2 on Cocaine for me. I didn't even bother with Oblivion on PC due to Computer not being upgraded.
no monies thanks to crap happening.