Neither. The only "Witch" one would shoot magic, so I wouldn't choose either of them. Maybe the Cryo gun. That looks like magic anyhow.

No. Seriously. Modded Hunting Rifle. The pipe weapons are dumb.

I'm at level 72 and one of my primary guns is still a fully modded hunting rifle. It's a recon .50 sniper rifle now. It's a great gun, but the .50 mod didn't quite bring the jump in damage that I was expecting.

HR's seem consistently better. But a Pipe-Rifle with a good mod......