I'd choose Deathclaw :hubbahubba:

Since we know nothing about the Big Horners stats, It's hard to say. They can knock us back pretty far from a description of them. I am looking forward to see the fight but the Deathclaw is the king of wasteland creatures. They have been the king in every fallout game, why change that now?

My money is on the deathclaws.

Slashing over blunt any day of the week.
I vote deathclaw.

One Creature battle I can't wait to see its Fire Gecko Vs Deathclaw. Both can kill someone in Power armour with little trouble. Fire vs Claws .

I'd imagine the Deathclaw would tear the Bighorn's insides out, then wear it's skin.

Wow, I wast the first one to vote for Big Horn.
So why I think it would win?
It's freaking massive man!
That thing would break every bone in a deathclaws skinny body.
Sure the goat would probably take a slash to it's side by the claw but I still think it would win.
I don't think a deathclaws intelligent enough to do a side-step out of harms way.
So first the charge would throw the Deathclaw backwards and make it fall to the ground, then it'd run over there and stomp it's face.
Also, they got bigger horns.

Big Horn = Win.

Big Horns Replace Brahmin I Do Not Believe A Brahmin Could Take On A Deatclaw

I don't think brahmins have been replaced.

This, i never had a deathclaw knock me 10 ft through the air. That thing was like a deathclaw and a half. Freakin massive. My money is on a bighorn as of right now. Cant wait to play and see the results for myself.

Big horn wins.

Atleast if deathclaws in fo:nv area act just like fo3 deathclaws and are lone predators. Eastcoast deathclaws should posess huge threat to big horn because they move in packs. Well actially i think they hunt in families as usually in fo2 deathclaw encounter had 2 big deathclaws and lots of smaller deathclaws.

So i say in duel big horn should win most of the times, but if death claw manages to surprise the big horn, then deathclaw might win. If deathclaws moves in packs, they will win easily any big horns.

ld

big horns ARE larger than deathclaws (or so they seem to be) so therefore shoud be able to take alot of damage

Big Horn, lol, look at its name how can it not win?

DEATHCLAW!!! Big horns seem like they would be too clumsy to go toe to toe with a deathclaw.

wow I actually want to see this one also. When I wrote my FO novel Of Your Shadows there is a pit battle in New Vegas featuring a Deathclaw fighting a batch of fire geckos. An apex predator against the only thing it would hesitate to attack...