If you're looking for something out of the usual, go blunt. If you want to go standard Paladin weaponry, go blade.
Also, I second the 40 willpower and 45 strength comment. While, yes, the difference is minor, Paladins (or, at the very least, D&D Paladins) have always been a mix between a strong mind and a strong body.
I would say 35 will and 55 strength is more important, you only lose 5 willpower but gain +10 strength and the other way you gain 5 will but lose 10 strength.
I woulda gone blade also. I would find the challenge to be choosing long sword & shield vs claymore. Pro's & cons to both for RP. From a stats perspective, a small nod goes to sword & board, but who cares 'bout that stuff since either will do the job just fine. :foodndrink: