So I had just finisshed "Trouble on the homefront" (by telling the rebels to stay) and knew i could get butch as a companian...but i had good karma, so i killed the bum at tenpenny, killed silver (the chick in springvale) and stole all of her stuff (litteraly, all of it, i double checked) and finally killed the rivet city bum...by now i finally have neutral karma, so i head down the starwell to the muddy rudder, there i find butch behind the counter , so i go up to him and heres what i get: " " a whole bunch of nothing! i tried reloading at least 5 times, but none of it worked...i tried punching him then talking to him, still nothing...i as wedll tried talking to him with good karma, and as you can guess...nothing...all help would be appreciated.

ps. i don't now if this will help but, i have the game of the year edition so i have all the DLCs, and i only got the game a few days ago and im playing the game on only one charector.

http://i142.photobucket.com/albums/r105/Enoil/DarkFishyStick.jpg

Did you try lowering your karma before doing "Trouble on the Homefront"?

See if that works.