i don't know why but the romance option won't appear. I have 16 charisma and 8 luck, i complete her personal quest so she's like totally into me, i sucessfully flirt with her way back in the game once but somehow the romance option won't appear. Everytime i ask her about our relationship or about the situation going on, she says something then it's back to the same dialogue choices where i can't do nothing but ask her about our relationship and the situuation going on. What am I doing wrong? Did she friendzone me or something? I'm about to go with Piper if she keeps doing that.

Have been too much "mr Nice guy" around the commonwealth?

Try to pick som locks, drink some alcohol and strutt around naked in town and you will "grow in her book". that should fix it!

dude, i probably lockpick like the entire commonwealth and alcohol no longer affect her approval when you complete her personal quest. I'll try to lockpick even more i guess, there's no other options.

There are 4 events per companions, i dont know how many of those conversations you had but if you haven talked with her 4 times then your affinity still needs to grow more.

I think that i talked with her 4 times already. First time was when she asked me why i was helping her. Second time was when she told me her backstory. Third time was when she told me that she needed to stop her drug addiction and Fouth time was after she was cure from her drug addiction. I never had the romance option at any point tho

When you say after you cured her addiction do you mean immediately after she got out of the chair? If so you have to continue raising her affinity. Also if lock picking isn't your bag or you can't find any just strip and fast travel to towns. I ported back and forth from Goodneighbor to Bunker Hill in nothing but my skivvies and sunglasses until she idolised me. Slow going but effective.

I like immersion and all, but this thread makes me glad I have a GF...

Hahaha...

Don't complain on my e-girlfriend!!!

My wife doesn't mind!

holy crap! I fast travel to Goodneighboor naked one time and it worked! I should had done that from the start instead of searching everywhere for locks to pick. Thanks guys!

Yep, in games, as in life, showing up naked on a date will get you the girl every time!