While playing Piper became my favorite companion. The problem is that when I reached "Idolized" with her the option to romance didn't come up. From what I've seen elsewhere you're supposed to be able to press the Y button to perform a persuasion check, but there the Y button is blank and pressing it does nothing. I have 9 Charisma and Level 2 Lady Killer so I've passed every flirt option so that's not the issue. I have tried hard resetting my Xbox to no avail. Any other suggestions out there?