l) Which is pretty much useless when you're stealthy.
m) Mr. A with his German Shepard, because he has much more supplies than Mr B. Simple as that.
Dogs are better at fighting and warning.
Useful tools for survival however they also need feeding and they eat alot more than cats.
Dogs are the "Comfy living" Wastelanders pet.
Cats hunt and fetch constantly, for anyone who has ever had a cat you will know this.
They also eat alot less than dogs.
Cats are smart and intellegent and will avoid prey whist hunting, domestic dogs are often reckless and raised wild dogs could probably not be trained.
Cats are the "Poor wastelander scraping to survive" perfect pet.
If your a raider in your bad ass fort full of food and a constant residence so you can breed dogs...
They will be good tools to survive and ward off prey.
If your a normal wastelander and you happen to have a cat, im sure you will much appreciate the constant offering of dead rodents and small birds ec cetera.
A man can survive on a rat per day for a long time and if your cat brought it, you dont have to even work for it.
Also your cat is less of a drain on food as it eats alot less than a dog.
Finally a Cat will be less inclined to attract attention due to its light footed and stealthy nature meaning there si a less chance it will attract attention to its self or you.
There is no saying either is better but I would take a cat.