As long as the cities are comparable to New Sheoth (Shivering Isles capital city). I spent so much time just in Crucible, and never spent too much time in Bliss (I loved Crucible way too much!). So if they can just get a proper layout, proper characters, and proper quests into each city to make them feel alive and unique, I'll be happy.
Crucible wasn't even that big, AT ALL, and it's still by far my favorite place in all of Oblivion/Shivering Isles.
Agreed. Layout, architectural design, characters, how the place ties in with the surrounding area and overall world, those points are far more important than just the size. That's what makes a city or town come alive.
yeah, the cities in Daggerfall were definitely massive, but they were boring... Morrowind had pretty small cities, but many of them had something indescribable... personality maybe.
on the other hand vivec was pretty big, and it was kind of a boring place to travel through, although it still had its charm
Oblivion cities had little charm. I, however, liked Anvil, but all the other cities seemed boring to me.
Ja Vivec was huge, as was Cyrodill city. Basically the last two massive cities we've had and both just didn't do it for me. They felt cumbersome to travel and uninspiring to spend much time in. Compare Vivec to Suran, and I'd pick Suran any time. It felt more natural and like a real town. Of couse, they also had the only nudie bar.. :hubbahubba: