Reach as great as they make it out to be?
It could be if you were able to choose your own weapons in more game modes and they removed a few of the power weapons, the matchmaking selection for Reach is laughable at best compared to server systems unless you're a DMR (Reach's short rifle) [censored] and you can get over the fact that Reach's bloom system is a steaming load of RNG. The only playlists which have different weapon loadouts are Firefight which has you facing AI covenant, and Invasion which only lets you choose your weapon after two up to for minute sessions of choiceless loadouts. To top it off, Bungie actually removed some of the custom game options from Halo 3 such as Infection Alpha Zombies, which was a huge slap in the face to most people who actually paid attention to their friend lists.
Forge World and Armor Abilities are at least fun if you're into map maping and/or into more than just run and gun games respectivly.
(Oh, and off topic thread ftw)