Playing skyrim recently, I started to notice just how many different people effectively owned my character's soul. Sithis, Nocturnal, Hircine, possibly Shor... and thats just from Skyrim. I think there are more but I cant recall, especially since some of the daedra princes are ambiguous at best about the idea. If we count earlier games im sure there are a lot more such factions.

So I got to wondering...Who has priority? From in-game events we can assume that Hircine gets priority over Shor... But what happens when you are both a thrall to Hircine *and* Nocturnal? There are obviously many such conflicts but I decided to use the most recent one for simplicity... Does anyone have any thoughts?

Not this again.............
You mantle something become a god and no one gets your soul you screw everyone over-Just a guess really.

I'd say that Hircine owns it, assuming you're a werewolf. After all, being a werewolf consumes your whole being.
But maybe if Nocturnal asked nicely enough, Hircine would give it to her Nocturnal might steal it back if she fancies it.

Then Mora throws your soul into a bookstack and tells the other two "Good luck finding it!"

Dovahkiin - Plaything of the Daedra.