So I have successfully completed the "Defend The Castle" (2nd time) now I'm supposed to talk with Ronnie Shaw, but I can only trade with her. The icon is above her head, indicating I need to interact with her, but it glitches out, and even activates conversation with her(and others at the Castle) without pushing a button. Has anyone experienced this? any ideas? I'm on XBox1. Thanks

I'm having a similar issue, but on the PS4. I am currently attempting to complete "Defending the Castle" and I'm stuck at 80% progress, due to the fact that no Brotherhood members will spawn to complete the quest. Have you had any luck so far?

Did you try leaving the area and coming back? Go through a loading screen it's helped me before.

Thanks for your reply. Yes, I have tried leaving the area, going all the way south, back up north, west, east, etc., going to Sanctuary, saving and so on...

You probably already tried this but, you may need to wait till the evening. Ronnie runs the armory and therefore interactions with her are generally limited until she has closed the Armory for the day ( she's kinda like a settler you assign to work at a shop, you can't interact the same way with a settler that is working at a shop VS. not working at a shop)

That could be it.

Thanks Galaxy, I will try it and keep you posted.

Nothing is working. I have waited several game days, but no change. Sturges is stuck outside just standing by the buildings like he's waiting for something else to happen, the Minutemen are still hanging out, but the quest says I successfully defended the castle. Oh well, I have completed all other quests, so I will just move on for now...kind of annoying tho