IDK what topics you've been hanging around in, but in the ones I participate in its actually the guys complaining about the pessimists that are guilty of not discussing things in a realistic fashion.
Skyrim is doing a lot of good. But its also doing quite a lot of bad. Neither trumps the other.
Exactly.
"For every action in the Universe, there is an Equal, Opposite Re-action."
For everything that has been removed, something has been added. Some of the changes will work, other's won't. Without this change and experimentation, BGS cannot learn and improve in later installments.
Simply put, things must change in order to survive. The Flaws of games are equally as important as the Good parts.