and this is why they fail, Sniper is particularly useless, as most snipers are too far away to use VATS satisfactorilly.
I disagree. It is worthless for long range, but it rocks mid-close range. Espeically with a high spread weapon like a shotgun or SMG. Love head shot shotgun blasts!
I guess the problem is calling it "Sniper" when it's intended for relatively close range (much less use a shotgun!) I think I would rename the perk to "Get Ahead" or maybe "Heady--That's Headly--Lamar"