I'm happy for you that you can play that way and enjoy it. Personally, I don't see any reason to do it. It seems completely in the class of "No one needs a speedometer in their car - if I can tell how fast I'm going by the pitch of the RPMs, everyone can!" Or "We don't need to waste ink marking the buttons on keyboards. I can touch type, why can't everyone?"
Not sure if that is a good anology. It is more like "no one needs a GPS navigator complete with back up camera" in their car because a map and a rear view mirror work just fine.
@Elricwulf and Sokjal: The OP is not trying to "force" anything on anyone. He is trying to open people's eyes to the possibility of something they might never tried otherwise.
I am a recent no-HUD convert. I have been playing TES games for years with no crosshair and have been annoyed that I cannot turn off sneak crosshair, compass icons or red dots. Since I am on a PS3, I cannot just mod/ini my way out of these.
I had tried turning off HUD entirely but soon gave up out of frustration with not knowing what my health was, but after reading a thread similar to this one and hearing the strategies folks use for keeping tabs on their health, I decided to give it another go, and now I would never go back to the HUD.
I am glad we have threads like these to get the word out, because I never would have stuck with it myself without these types of threads and I am so glad I did stick with it.
In an ideal world, we would have the option to independantly turn off sneak crosshair, compass icons and the compass itself, but TES is far from an ideal world. For those of us on PS3 or Xbox, the only option for no compass, no sneak crosshair play is to turn off the entire HUD.