Yeah if NV doesn't win Game of the Year from somebody notable then I hope they don't call it that.
Release with "Deluxe" or "Gold" or "Something" Edition, but not GOTY.
It'd be tacky to just slap it on there to make it sound cool.
I remember when FO3 won GOTY, how proud I was that "my" game won the award, but then I saw some other games slap it on their cover just because "Western France Magazine of the PC Gamer" thought it was the best, and remembering how irritated I was that some "hoe-dunk" game was trying to creep in on the title.
I just figure it'd be hypocritical of me now to think that NV now should put GOTY on the cover just because some cheesy magazine nobody cares for thinks it is. Not that it wouldn't get the award in my book...
NV did get some GOTY awards from some mags, and it won many RPG of the year awards, and many more best writing awards than FO3 did, so I think its fair that it gets a GOTY release, after all, it was better than FO3.