Board-game play is a lesser role-play and is less true to the role that you are playing. It's as simple as that.
Fallout 3 was far more true to the role that you played.
Fallout 3 some of the awards:-
------------- -----------------
IGN -- Best RPG--Game of the Year 2008
GameSpot -- Best RPG--Best PC Game
Game Critics Awards --Best RPG and Best of Show for E3 2008
PC Gamer gave Fallout 3 2nd place on its '100 Best PC games of all time' list, praising its user-modifications, deep gameplay and overall polish.
------------- -----------------
Fallout 3 was far more true to the role that you played.
Fallout 3 some of the awards:-
------------- -----------------
IGN -- Best RPG--Game of the Year 2008
GameSpot -- Best RPG--Best PC Game
Game Critics Awards --Best RPG and Best of Show for E3 2008
PC Gamer gave Fallout 3 2nd place on its '100 Best PC games of all time' list, praising its user-modifications, deep gameplay and overall polish.
------------- -----------------
fallout 1 won rpg of the year to
Board game style games or 3d games does not change the rpg characteristics