There's 1 reason why some people didn't fully enjoy Automatron.
I created a new character to play Automatron and I am having a blast, I still haven't unlocked all options. It was also a bit difficult for me, the final battle took me several tries, I died really easily with all the mobs and explosions everywhere because of my level.
However there are other people out there who tried the DLC with their endgame "main" characters, and those people didn't really encountered any challenge, and they completly depleted the enjoyment and surprises of Automatron rather quick on their first try. If you have around 300 hours with one character, I imagine you already have everything you need to craft numerous kinds of robots, and you probably finished the Automatron quest without even trying.
This leads me to a certain fear, because I liked Automatron so much that I am planning to use the same character for Far Harbor, and I am afraid I will not enjoy it much because everything will be underlevel, all enemies and bosses will be balanced for lowbies, all loot will feel useless compared to what I will have when I try it. I imagine my Robot with Mininukes and Gatlings will just let me forget there are even enemies in that new huge landmass.
What do you guys prefer?
would you rather have a DLC for endgame players who already beat the main quest and got the best weapons? (like Point Lookout)
Or you prefer to have a DLC for lowbies like Automatron?