FEV destroyed at meriposa and oil righ

Post » Wed Feb 24, 2010 7:24 pm

I havent played F1 or 2 and would like to get them in the fiture.

but i see a lot of talk on this board that the FEV couldnt be in F3, cause it was destroyed in previous fallouts.
looking at the cvault wiki, i cant find anyting that says it was destroyed.. merely that sixond gen mutant army was sealed at mariposa ruind and that samples takend from there went tot he oil rig, which was destroyed.


so to those who have played the first two games, were the mariposa ruins merely selaed by the enclave, or was there some reference that all FEV was destroyed?


thanks
User avatar
Undisclosed Desires
 
Posts: 3388
Joined: Fri Mar 02, 2007 4:10 pm

Post » Thu Feb 25, 2010 2:41 am

It's not about it being destroyed. It's about there being no indication whatsoever that any FEV was ever present anywhere but in West-Tek, where it was created, and in Mariposa, where it was transferred by the military. There are holodisks detailing the FEV research and none of them indicated any possibility of any FEV being experimented on elsewhere.
User avatar
Nichola Haynes
 
Posts: 3457
Joined: Tue Aug 01, 2006 4:54 pm

Post » Thu Feb 25, 2010 1:37 am

There is an issue we may not be looking at- we're talking about records that are over 200 years old, and that was heavily classified by the US Government.

Most info stored on the terminals would've been wiped from the Nuclear bombs (they create a EMP wave that overloads electronics in the area, permanently disabling them.) Anything on paper would have to have been stored in a relativly dry area, safe from local pests, otherwise there'd be little left of it after 200 years. Filing cabinents, even secure ones, are not moisture controlled and can easily be penetrated by bugs, mice, etc. Holodiscs, i'm not so sure of. They look like they run on a similar basis to cassettes; if this is the case, most would be wiped due to that EMP wave. And the usual procedure to classified documents when you need to hastily vacate the premesis is to burn/erase them so the enemy can't get a hold of the information.

So if there were records that there were other storage areas for the FEV, it's quite likely they could have been destroyed before anyone could find it.
User avatar
Latisha Fry
 
Posts: 3399
Joined: Sat Jun 24, 2006 6:42 am

Post » Wed Feb 24, 2010 11:58 pm

AUSIR<
so is it, in your opinion at least theoretically possible for FEV to exist outside of mariposa, west tek or the oil rig




Is there in F3 evidence that that vault had started as an FEV test facility?
i know the wikia does.. but i dont remeber it specifically in the actual game....
User avatar
Vera Maslar
 
Posts: 3468
Joined: Wed Sep 27, 2006 2:32 pm

Post » Wed Feb 24, 2010 9:16 pm

There is an issue we may not be looking at- we're talking about records that are over 200 years old, and that was heavily classified by the US Government.

Most info stored on the terminals would've been wiped from the Nuclear bombs (they create a EMP wave that overloads electronics in the area, permanently disabling them.) Anything on paper would have to have been stored in a relativly dry area, safe from local pests, otherwise there'd be little left of it after 200 years. Filing cabinents, even secure ones, are not moisture controlled and can easily be penetrated by bugs, mice, etc. Holodiscs, i'm not so sure of. They look like they run on a similar basis to cassettes; if this is the case, most would be wiped due to that EMP wave. And the usual procedure to classified documents is to burn/erase them so the enemy can't get a hold of them when faced with the need to vacate a base or sensitive area.

So if there were records that there were other storage areas for the FEV, it's quite likely they could have been destroyed before anyone could find it.



It depends on if you think breaking canon means including something that is not mentioned, or doing something that is contraray to established story. To me if there is nothing in canon taht contradicts the new story, then it's ok, because no baseline has been established in that instance.

Then again, i don't place much importance in franchise canon as long as each game is consistent within itself.
User avatar
Kelli Wolfe
 
Posts: 3440
Joined: Thu Aug 23, 2007 7:09 am

Post » Thu Feb 25, 2010 1:19 am

FEV was a "secret weapon" first ruel of secret weapons is keep them secret. Have a public FEV test vault doesn't coninside with it staying secret. Generally super secret government project have one location. The mere fact that the Enclave have to break in to take the samples should suggest that it was the only place that had it.
User avatar
R.I.P
 
Posts: 3370
Joined: Sat Dec 01, 2007 8:11 pm

Post » Wed Feb 24, 2010 6:54 pm

FEV was a "secret weapon" first ruel of secret weapons is keep them secret. Have a public FEV test vault doesn't coninside with it staying secret. Generally super secret government project have one location. The mere fact that the Enclave have to break in to take the samples should suggest that it was the only place that had it.

it really only suggests that the enclave only knew about one place.


also, even with secret weapons, you need more than one batch to experiment on/with.. a controll run and runs with variables.
not only for the FEV but for the subjects its used on..

as far as the whole holotpe not disclosing anoher location, it bering a secred weapon does apply.
if you had a secret weapon, i shoudlnt think you would keep all of your eggs in one basket. rather youd have a few locations, but no information linking the two (or more) places... in the event of oneplace being found out, you wouldnt give the "enemy" a map to the other locations.




regardless. im asking for something aside from spectualtion.
proof
User avatar
Cassie Boyle
 
Posts: 3468
Joined: Sun Nov 05, 2006 9:33 am

Post » Thu Feb 25, 2010 2:31 am

There is an issue we may not be looking at- we're talking about records that are over 200 years old, and that was heavily classified by the US Government.

Most info stored on the terminals would've been wiped from the Nuclear bombs (they create a EMP wave that overloads electronics in the area, permanently disabling them.) Anything on paper would have to have been stored in a relativly dry area, safe from local pests, otherwise there'd be little left of it after 200 years. Filing cabinents, even secure ones, are not moisture controlled and can easily be penetrated by bugs, mice, etc. Holodiscs, i'm not so sure of. They look like they run on a similar basis to cassettes; if this is the case, most would be wiped due to that EMP wave. And the usual procedure to classified documents when you need to hastily vacate the premesis is to burn/erase them so the enemy can't get a hold of the information.

So if there were records that there were other storage areas for the FEV, it's quite likely they could have been destroyed before anyone could find it.

Actually, EMP destroys transistors and PCBs. Machines in Fallout were all vacuum-tube based, so they would be immune to EMP. Plus, F1 is set 80 years after the war, not 200.
User avatar
Russell Davies
 
Posts: 3429
Joined: Wed Nov 07, 2007 5:01 am

Post » Thu Feb 25, 2010 7:00 am

Actually, EMP destroys transistors and PCBs. Machines in Fallout were all vacuum-tube based, so they would be immune to EMP. Plus, F1 is set 80 years after the war, not 200.

ya, ia agree with the terminals themselves.. but what about holotapes?
User avatar
u gone see
 
Posts: 3388
Joined: Tue Oct 02, 2007 2:53 pm

Post » Wed Feb 24, 2010 11:26 pm

It depends on if you think breaking canon means including something that is not mentioned, or doing something that is contraray to established story. To me if there is nothing in canon taht contradicts the new story, then it's ok, because no baseline has been established in that instance.

Then again, i don't place much importance in franchise canon as long as each game is consistent within itself.


This.

There's nothing in Fallout or Fallout 2 saying that there can't be other FEV test sites outside of Mariposa. Whether it makes sense or not depends on who you ask, it doesn't really bother me but some seem to think it's a stretch for Vault 87 to be yet another FEV test site.
User avatar
Thomas LEON
 
Posts: 3420
Joined: Mon Nov 26, 2007 8:01 am

Post » Wed Feb 24, 2010 8:01 pm

it really only suggests that the enclave only knew about one place.


also, even with secret weapons, you need more than one batch to experiment on/with.. a controll run and runs with variables.
not only for the FEV but for the subjects its used on..

as far as the whole holotpe not disclosing anoher location, it bering a secred weapon does apply.
if you had a secret weapon, i shoudlnt think you would keep all of your eggs in one basket. rather youd have a few locations, but no information linking the two (or more) places... in the event of oneplace being found out, you wouldnt give the "enemy" a map to the other locations.




regardless. im asking for something aside from spectualtion.
proof


Well for one, you don't need separate geographical locations to have more than one batch to experiment with or subjects to experiment on. Rooms or buildings work well. And with a secret weapon, ideally you want to keep its existence confined to one place. FEV's presence in Fallout 3 was a rehash, but it was bit of a bother to see Vault-Tec doing FEV research in a vault on the East Coast (why not a Vault closer to West-Tek if it has to).
User avatar
Neliel Kudoh
 
Posts: 3348
Joined: Thu Oct 26, 2006 2:39 am

Post » Thu Feb 25, 2010 4:33 am

Well for one, you don't need separate geographical locations to have more than one batch to experiment with or subjects to experiment on. Rooms or buildings work well. And with a secret weapon, ideally you want to keep its existence confined to one place. FEV's presence in Fallout 3 was a rehash, but it was bit of a bother to see Vault-Tec doing FEV research in a vault on the East Coast (why not a Vault closer to West-Tek if it has to).

well that would be why its scientific...


yo have a completely differtn base of people from coast to coast... different diets... many many variables at different locations.

but again, you would want more than one place, so if something was botched youd still have somethingto work with.... and not just botched by they scientists, but by people infiltrating and so on..

so you make another location..
and destroy any evidence of them being linked, in case the other is found out..



but again.. these points (both your points and mine) are spectulative.
i want actual proof..

its my hypothesis that there isnt...
but i would love someone to prove me wrong with facts
User avatar
Ross Thomas
 
Posts: 3371
Joined: Sat Jul 21, 2007 12:06 am

Post » Thu Feb 25, 2010 7:51 am

its my hypothesis that there isnt...
but i would love someone to prove me wrong with facts


If there were facts that there weren't FEV test sites besides Mariposa then Bethesda probably wouldn't have included Vault 87 as an FEV Vault in Fallout 3.
User avatar
Miss K
 
Posts: 3458
Joined: Sat Jan 20, 2007 2:33 pm

Post » Wed Feb 24, 2010 9:03 pm

If there were facts that there weren't FEV test sites besides Mariposa then Bethesda probably wouldn't have included Vault 87 as an FEV Vault in Fallout 3.


Haha, I doubt that. We needed our Orc opposition. And there's still no need for their to be two or more research facilities, if you're experimenting on people and need to know how it'll affect New Yorkers...you can just bring them to the facility. And one place is far easier to secure than many. Still don't know why Vault-Tec was chosen to do it, they could easily have thrown a West-Tek lab in.
User avatar
Jade MacSpade
 
Posts: 3432
Joined: Thu Jul 20, 2006 9:53 pm

Post » Thu Feb 25, 2010 4:59 am

If there were facts that there weren't FEV test sites besides Mariposa then Bethesda probably wouldn't have included Vault 87 as an FEV Vault in Fallout 3.

i agree


Malcador.
of course its speculation.. ive covered that already
User avatar
Karen anwyn Green
 
Posts: 3448
Joined: Thu Jun 15, 2006 4:26 pm

Post » Thu Feb 25, 2010 6:06 am

Haha, I doubt that. We needed our Orc opposition. And there's still no need for their to be two or more research facilities, if you're experimenting on people and need to know how it'll affect New Yorkers...you can just bring them to the facility. And one place is far easier to secure than many. Still don't know why Vault-Tec was chosen to do it, they could easily have thrown a West-Tek lab in.


Considering West-Tek's absence in Fallout 3, and Bethesda's failure to mention them in any Vault 87 computers... I think it's a safe bet the Bethesda forgot that West-Tek existed.
User avatar
El Khatiri
 
Posts: 3568
Joined: Sat Sep 01, 2007 2:43 am

Post » Wed Feb 24, 2010 11:56 pm

As Ausir has stated, the only two pre-war locations of FEV were West Tek, and then Mariposa. Mariposa was the only source of post-war FEV.

This is what has been established in both the Fallout Bible, and the Fallout Timeline.

Fallout: Brotherhood of Steel, a game that heavily contradicts established canon, had a private Vault for personal Vault-Tec use, that had FEV present. Not only does it contradict canon, but it also makes little sense. Vault-Tec constructed their own private Vault because they didn't want to risk being thrown in with the public experimentation Vaults. So to then experiment with FEV in their own Vault is the compromising risk they wanted to avoid in the first place.

Fallout 3, another game that heavily contradicts established canon, has Vault 87. A Vault that was built in 2071 for FEV experimentation. FEV didn't exsist until 2075. (I'll also state that while canon in Fallout 3 is naturally considered official - because the current owners of the franchise endorse it - it doesn't make the contradictions of the established canon any less true).

So whilst FEV does apparently exist in locations other than Mariposa before the Great War according to Bethesda, it isn't entirely agreeable to everyone.
User avatar
Dean
 
Posts: 3438
Joined: Fri Jul 27, 2007 4:58 pm

Post » Thu Feb 25, 2010 10:52 am

As Ausir has stated, the only two pre-war locations of FEV were West Tek, and then Mariposa. Mariposa was the only source of post-war FEV.

This is what has been established in both the Fallout Bible, and the Fallout Timeline.


written proof from both of those sources that say indesputably that those are the only places it exists, please
User avatar
Solina971
 
Posts: 3421
Joined: Thu Mar 29, 2007 6:40 am

Post » Thu Feb 25, 2010 5:06 am

That wiki is an awesome thing, has this search ability I hear. Although another way they could have shoe-horned FEV into this, was just have the Enclave running the whole show of SMs - say they brought some of it East as well as to the refinery and have the SMs around for some purpose (training, boogeyman to scare people into thinking they're good, etc.). Oh well, we just to have accept what Bethesda tossed us for FEV being here.
User avatar
Haley Merkley
 
Posts: 3356
Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 12:53 pm

Post » Thu Feb 25, 2010 7:07 am

That wiki is an awesome thing, has this search ability I hear.

i am not the one claiming that vault 87 is out of cannon, or that it cant possibly be because all of the FEV ever was in mariposa.. so the burden of proof isnt upon me. that was a nice try, though......

besides,I have been looking thought both the vault wikia and the Fallout bible duck and cover anyway.
User avatar
lucy chadwick
 
Posts: 3412
Joined: Mon Jul 10, 2006 2:43 am

Post » Wed Feb 24, 2010 11:44 pm

i am not the one claiming that vault 87 is out of cannon, or that it cant possibly be because all of the FEV ever was in mariposa.. so the burden of proof isnt upon me. that was a nice try, though......

besides,I have been looking thought both the vault wikia and the Fallout bible duck and cover anyway.


Well you were told where to find the info, so not sure what your demand for written proof was for - so hence the search. Vault 87 is in canon now, thanks to Bethesda, whether or not it makes sense in the game's lore is another issue (had to have it though, we needed SMs and FEV to relate to the older games, heh). While there's no explicit statement that FEV only existed at West-Tek and was moved to Mariposa, it does seem logical that it's true.
User avatar
Andres Lechuga
 
Posts: 3406
Joined: Sun Aug 12, 2007 8:47 pm

Post » Thu Feb 25, 2010 7:25 am

[quote name='Kickstand27' post='14364556' date='May 21 2009, 12:08 AM']written proof from both of those sources that say indesputably that those are the only places it exists, please[/quote]
From the [src="http://fallout.wikia.com/wiki/Timeline"]Fallout Timeline[/url]:
[quote name='Fallout Timeline, 2055']The West Tek Research Facility starts working on a new virus to kill the New Plague. Their viral research and close ties to the federal government eventually lead to them being chosen for the Pan-Immunity Virion Project twenty years later as well as Power Infantry Armor and laser research[/quote][quote name='Fallout Timeline, 2073']September 15: As China becomes increasingly aggressive with their use of biological weapons, the United States government felt that a countermeasure was needed. The Pan-Immunity Virion Project (PVP) is officially formed and plans are made to begin experiments at the WestTek research facility in Southern California[/quote][quote name='Fallout Timeline, 2075']March 21: PVP experiments continue at West Tek with batch 10-011, in the wake of successful tests of the virus on single-celled organisms. Experiments on plant cells are postponed. The pan-immunity virion is renamed FEV - the Forced Evolutionary Virus.
May 9: FEV experiments continue at West Tek with batch 10-011, in the wake of successful tests on flatworms, the flatworms exhibit increase size and heightened resistance to viral contagions. Experiments with insects have less success, and further experimentation on insects is postponed by Major Barnett.
June 30: FEV experiments continue at West Tek with batch 10-011, with white mice as subjects. Increased size, muscle density, and intelligence are noted.
November 9: FEV experimentation (batch 10-011) on rabbits is concluded. Increased size, intelligence, and (this time) aggressiveness is noted. Apparently, it was hard to determine whether the flatworms in the previous experiments were angrier and more violent than normal. Frankly, the researchers cannot be blamed for this.[/quote][quote name='Fallout Timeline, 2076']April 15: Once all secondary tests and studies are done on the test subjects, all dogs from the batch 11-101a FEV tests at West Tek are terminated...from a safe distance[/quote][quote name='Fallout Timeline, 2077']January 7: Major Barnett orders transfer of all FEV research to the newly-constructed Mariposa Military Base, despite objections by the research team[/quote]
This is what has been established.
User avatar
Nikki Morse
 
Posts: 3494
Joined: Fri Aug 25, 2006 12:08 pm

Post » Wed Feb 24, 2010 8:19 pm

Well you were told where to find the info, so not sure what your demand for written proof was for - so hence the search. Vault 87 is in canon now, thanks to Bethesda, whether or not it makes sense in the game's lore is another issue (had to have it though, we needed SMs and FEV to relate to the older games, heh). While there's no explicit statement that FEV only existed at West-Tek and was moved to Mariposa, it does seem logical that it's true.

like i said, ive been looking in those places, and i cant find it..
but before you even clicked on this link you should have read "proof?" which notes im asking for it.
i also mentioned that i dont believe there is any, which means i may have looked before even asking


of course its much easier to say "Look for it your self" when you dont know the answer


The West Tek Research Facility starts working on a new virus to kill the New Plague. Their viral research and close ties to the federal government eventually lead to them being chosen for the Pan-Immunity Virion Project twenty years later as well as Power Infantry Armor and laser research
QUOTE (Fallout Timeline, 2073)
September 15: As China becomes increasingly aggressive with their use of biological weapons, the United States government felt that a countermeasure was needed. The Pan-Immunity Virion Project (PVP) is officially formed and plans are made to begin experiments at the WestTek research facility in Southern California
QUOTE (Fallout Timeline, 2075)
March 21: PVP experiments continue at West Tek with batch 10-011, in the wake of successful tests of the virus on single-celled organisms. Experiments on plant cells are postponed. The pan-immunity virion is renamed FEV - the Forced Evolutionary Virus.
May 9: FEV experiments continue at West Tek with batch 10-011, in the wake of successful tests on flatworms, the flatworms exhibit increase size and heightened resistance to viral contagions. Experiments with insects have less success, and further experimentation on insects is postponed by Major Barnett.
June 30: FEV experiments continue at West Tek with batch 10-011, with white mice as subjects. Increased size, muscle density, and intelligence are noted.
November 9: FEV experimentation (batch 10-011) on rabbits is concluded. Increased size, intelligence, and (this time) aggressiveness is noted. Apparently, it was hard to determine whether the flatworms in the previous experiments were angrier and more violent than normal. Frankly, the researchers cannot be blamed for this.
QUOTE (Fallout Timeline, 2076)
April 15: Once all secondary tests and studies are done on the test subjects, all dogs from the batch 11-101a FEV tests at West Tek are terminated...from a safe distance
QUOTE (Fallout Timeline, 2077)
January 7: Major Barnett orders transfer of all FEV research to the newly-constructed Mariposa Military Base, despite objections by the research team

again, im looking for conclusive eveidence that it didn't exist anywhere else, not evidence of where it did exist. thre is a difference.
User avatar
Céline Rémy
 
Posts: 3443
Joined: Sat Apr 07, 2007 12:45 am

Post » Thu Feb 25, 2010 7:34 am

like i said, ive been looking in those places, and i cant find it..
but before you even clicked on this link you should have read "proof?" which notes im asking for it.
i also mentioned that i dont believe there is any, which means i may have looked before even asking


of course its much easier to say "Look for it your self" when you dont know the answer


Well if you look above, that's some decent proof from the canon. Heh, I'm reminded of Rummy's quotes about the absence of evidence - maybe the Master did clone himself and send his clone to Florida. After all, it's not stated he never did it.
User avatar
Tha King o Geekz
 
Posts: 3556
Joined: Mon May 07, 2007 9:14 pm

Post » Thu Feb 25, 2010 7:21 am

Well if you look above, that's some decent proof from the canon. Heh, I'm reminded of Rummy's quotes about the absence of evidence - maybe the Master did clone himself and send his clone to Florida. After all, it's not stated he never did it.

exactly..

thank you for agreeing that proof that mariposa was the only place where FEV was located doesnt exist.

wouldnt it have been a lot easier to say that before doing things like asking me to do a search on a wikia site for what you knew wasnt there?
User avatar
Eoh
 
Posts: 3378
Joined: Sun Mar 18, 2007 6:03 pm

Next

Return to Fallout Series Discussion