If they've done finishing moves for every time you kill an enemy, it will become very tedious.
Finishing moves should be for special moments, like stealth kills and maybe give the option to do more powerful moves that might result in a finishing move if done as the killing blow.
So just using disarm & knockdown moves in oblivion was'nt tedious was it?
I still like that now as most did...at the time 99 % of us loved oblivion.....with finishers we have more to do in combat...it gives more satisfaction,especially with having different ones for different enemies & weapons.Some people are just never happy.
At least bethesda have the balls to try new things....its how they will improve....everything cant be kept the same forever.
Also people need to realise...you cant please everyone as a developer.
Like i've said with other things before,people would mod them anyway.There was a mod for oblivion & morrowind that allowed finish moves & it was popular...if as a dev you knew people found it fun/popular,would'nt you apply that to future games you make?