I only got to play during the last beta, and only a little bit. Overall...YES...totally worth it! I had a blast! It's a fun game for sure. Yes, I had some frustrating moments, and I didn't love absolutely every aspect of the game, but I liked it enough to pre-order and try it for the first month at least. I have a feeling I will continue to subscribe after my free month is up
That being said, my main problems with it were:
-Crashing (it was a stress test though so I sort of expected that)
-Bugged dialog with npc's (I would have to do /reloadui - many times per session)
I'm sure these things will be mostly ironed out at launch. I expect these minor issues will continue to pop up HERE AND THERE for a little while after launch while they keep tuning the game - but eventually it wil all stabilize.
Crafting:
-I had trouble finding the right npc's sometimes (this is due in part to the fact that they don't have nameplates like WoW or other MMO's - and also due to my aging memory)
-Once I found the right people, I didn't know what to do (in other words, I didn't know HOW to enchant, HOW to use the BS station etc - Most of these things will be addressed by a) having a manual handy once the game is launched just remembering how to do stuff)
I am confident that all these things will be addressed, on their end AND my end. I'm am confident that Zenimax will continue to fine tune the content, add more, remove stuff etc until the game runs great for almost everyone.
Folks, Zenimax is listening! I think they really want this game to be a success and are going to be really invested in it for a long time to come. They have already addressed two of the biggest gripes to come out of the last beta and I think that shows they trully do care about OUR experience. I do think they have their work cut out for them; some people will not even consider it because it's quite different from WoW etc. Some people will not consider it because it's quite a bit different from other ES titles. But if you keep in mind that it is it's own thing, and not expect it to be Skyrim OR WoW, then you're in for a treat.
Plus, it's the best looking MMO ever and simply exploring the world they created will be worth it.
8.5/10 based on my limited experience with the game....I think that's a great score for a brand new MMO, and I expect that will go up even more in the future.
There's more I could say - I admittedly did not go to deeply into some of my thoughts - but the bottom line for me is, if you can afford the game (knowing that you may not like it and will stop playing after your free month) then get it. I think you'll dig it...just don't have too many expectations and realize it's kind of it's own thing.