As the title says...

I would definitely be a ghoul than a super mutant; you are immune to radiation, can blend in amongst ferals, so you aren't killed and eaten, and can live long lives.

Ghouls can turn stupid.

All Supermutants will turn stupid (save Mariposa ones, but they aren't in FO4).

Definitely a Ghoul.

You can remain yourself as a ghoul. I would choose a ghoul but I would rather put a bullet in my head than living a life looking like a corpse, smelling like a corpse, and being treated like a corpse.

Come on, you could live forever... together with Danse!

Both live hundreds of years and are immune to radiation, but only one can live a life like a normal human would almost.

The difference between an immortal burn victim that is immune to radiation and a ghoul is pretty much non-existent, so I'd take ghoul over Super Mutant.

The strength is nice, but that seems to be the only upside of a Super Mutant, and it seems like you are more likely to be shot at by any random person if you are a Super Mutant, whereas unless you are shuffling along, you could just wear a hat or hood and blend in pretty well as a ghoul.

Puny humans! This is the age of the SUPER MUTANT!!

Depends on if we're talking Mariposa super mutants or one of the two east coast strains. If Mariposa, mutie all the way!

As a "genetically clean" (that sounds so messed up) human, odds are I'll only become smarter on top of bigger and stronger. Sure, I'm steril now, but that would've happened anyway if I'd chosen ghoul, and this way I'm not slowly falling apart and potentially losing my mind.


If we're talking only east coast muties I take all tha back. I'd rather die than become one of those crazy bastards. Ghoul all day any day.

Think about the implications when you're a super mutant. You're stronger, tougher, and more rad resistant than any umie' out there. Now if you can somehow restore your intelligence, salvage a power armour and adapt it for your huge physique, plus gather an army you'd be unstoppable.

Can I be an antler worshiping nightkin? If not I guess ghoul.

Bring him to Mass Fusion and that hunk of metal thinks he was doing me a favor by killing me after becoming a ghoul. >:-(

Not sure if living forever with Danse means he'll just cut off my ghoul head and mount it on the wall.

Id rather lose my intelligence than have to peel the skin off my body because its all dying.

Yea no thanks that sounds horrible. Ill take super mutant for 500.

Back in the late 70's when I was just a teenager, you'd find me glued to the tv when David Banner transformed into "The Incredible Hulk", one of my favorite tv shows of all times. Anyway, I rather be a knuckle dragging Super Mutant than a rotting, goat smelling Ghoul.

Super Mutant so I could keep kidnapping those women at Abernathy farms.......you know, just to tick off that Lone wanderer

You would rather eat human flesh? Also, there's a chance you'd be suicide mutant, you know?

Only white meat, dark meat gives me indigestion.....

Why not a Ghoul-Supermutant hybrid?

ME EAT BRAIN!!!

....

I'd rather be an Assaultron with a fabulous personalty.

Edit- To answer the question: I'll be which ever one kills Preston.

I'd be too tempted to eat myself if I was a ghoul. They do look tasty though right? It's not just me?


It is just me, balls.

His last words would be "please help this settlement... (dead)"

You would be a strong independent assaultron who ain't need to man to keep her down.

But according to supermutants, ghouls taste terrible. Being a ghoul may actually spare you from being eaten by both ghouls and supermutants.

I would like to be a human who thinks they're a super mutant.

Ah, good. All the more for me.

Probably tough from all the radiation, kinda like an overcooked steak, all the flavors stripped from it. I'll (super mutant) stick with the settlers.

I'd be a ghoul (assuming that we're talking about a non-feral ghoul). Ghouls can at least blend into human society to at least some extent. Super mutants...not so much.

I would rather be a Super Mutant. Why be a walking corpse that will eventually turn feral?

There are synths living for hundreds of years without turning feral from before the war even, I would say they have higher lifespan than all the supermutants and humans ever lived. Supermutants also are under the threat of being hunted down and killed by everyone, especially the Sisterhood of Steel while regular ghouls at most just get driven out until you form a community of your own with other ghouls.