Umm, it lost the G4 GotY, so they cancel each other out.
Eat it...
Skyrim also got Machinima so...
But anyway I didn't realize GOTY awards were like matter/antimatter. Should have payed more attention in physics.
I assume, if a person takes GOTY awards seriously in their game purchases, that they would look at the particular award and think "Hmmm I am usually in agreement/disagreement with X".
If you like/respect G4 but not SpikeTV (or vice versa), then the award carries different weight. If you like both then I guess your head explodes.