Considering Tamriel is in it's "Dark Ages" in Skyrim, no. And ESPECIALLY not if they're not gonna at least add spears to balance it out.

But thanks for coming out and tryin'.

Guns? Who needs em?

Not warriors, or sorcerers. Probably not stealth users either, as they tend to be loud and clanky. So that leaves no one :celebration:

As long as the guns are worth using,then yes.I want them to have similar benifits like the magic has.This is what I mean.
Flamethrower deals maximum damage,Laser Rifle drains magicka and Grenade Launcher drains stamina and slows down enemies physically.I think this would be a great alternative for Warrior type characters who dont like using magic.
I personally would like to dual weild Grenade Launcher's but that's just me.
Here's another idea to consider and sorry if someone has already mentioned this,but what about remnant power armor?

Add a poll already, so you can watch as it racks up a 50 "for" to 300+ "against" result and get this over with...again...

Is your life so bad that you want to commit suicide
*slurp* continue

I don't even need to bother reading through this entire thread. If there were ever a topic that will stir a more passionate debate on this forum, I have yet to see it. Merely mentioning the addition of guns in TES is rivaled only by Fast Travel threads, or Morrowind vs. Oblivion threads. But, to add my two pence, I would absolutely stop playing TES if guns were ever added. :down:

NO...no..no
LOL.... thats the worst idea ive heard so far, why not bring in star trek into the Styrim to :banghead:

What I said in an earlier thread on this topic,



Concerning technological refinement, I think I would like to see advancements toward staff production and craftsmanship. Although we our 200 years in the furture, we have been told in interviews that the tech is more primitive. It could be cultural, in that the Nords are comfortable with the traditional tools of war, or the ruined Empire has lead to a decline.

We did something similar with the end of the Roman Empire, but we tend to over-exaggerate that. Nirn of course, is NOT Earth. It's a completely different world with a very unique history. They have Gods and Magic constantly building up and tearing down the world around them. They have real, distinct races, each with their own cultural understanding and interactions with these mysterious forces. They're a people trying to find stability in chaos and hope in uncertainty. Being a game and a story, it is of course a reflection of ourselves. For us, the players, we should be able to explore and learn about this world in a way that allows us to learn something about ourselves, the world we live in, and our place in it. For me, The Elder Scrolls is about doing something a lot of Role-playing games and adventure games try to do and fail. To Create a believable world, that can be explored and experienced, with entertaining things to do and see, but with important lessons and ideas to be learned and brought to mind concerning morality, human nature, politics, and religion. Elder Scrolls, Fallout, Myst, Zork, Half-Life, Bioshock, are really the only games that have really done this for me in different, but meaningful ways.

More on topic, guns are irrelevant, providing little to game-play / role-play, and nothing to what Skyrim is trying to do. It definitely won't improve or ruin my experience, same with spears and crossbows.

Lets kill this useless topic ! :violin:

The experimental MIRV from Fallout 3 as an easter egg, should make the OP happy.

But serously, I don't want to see or use a musket or anything else that uses black power and shoots metal balls. Blow-Dart "gun" is the most gun like thing I want, and that only because it is an awsome idea how to improve poisons in the game.

I wouldn't mind if there were ONE gun as a reward for a daedric quest, which you get by killing the guy who made it.

there should be a pack-a-punch at the top a mountain. this will allow me to upgrade my 1911 into a mustang and sally(dual grenade launching pistols) or transform a typical ray gun into a sixy portersxII ray gun. i want perks like commando(with no falling damage), steady aim, and danger close. wolves should drop max ammo, and i want stinger missles to shoot down spy planes.OOPS I MEAN DRAGONS

You forgot two more. Multiplayer threads and console vs pc threads are on par with the ones you mentioned as well.

And my reply to this thread is a simple but very effective...no.

If you want guns then they should add bombs too, and "fire-spears",which was a medieval prototype of a flamethrower in China.It was invented before the first muskets.It will ruin the game,think about it.
PS I am reading right now the book of Jack Kelly "Gunpowder — Alchemy, Bombards & Pyrotechnics." if you want guns read that book first.

And early Chinese missile launchers! :facepalm:

Yeap.But gunpowder doesnt even exist in the TES lore,so where wil be no guns in TES games.

Use the ol' "Dwemer excuse." :tongue:
Seriously though, please no guns!

and there we have it folks! No gunpowder! Can't make guns without blackpowder.

Yeap.Even if they added it now,in a history beetween first gunpowder was invented and the "right gunpowder" (i mean with the right consistency) passed almost 400 years.

No, just no.

Post limit.