If people can clamor for spears despite being flawed in their latest appearance within the series than us horse-lovers can do the same. Horse-lovers unite!
Indeed, sure, horses weren't done that well in Oblivion, but in their last appearance in the series, spears also weren't handled as well as they could have been, but that didn't stop anyone from wanting them, and that's perfectly reasonable, because removing something entirely isn't the only solution to a feature being implemented poorly, you can also try to improve on it. And maybe they'll do this to horses in Skyrim, Bethesda hasn't confirmed horses, certainly, but they haven't denied them either, so we'll just see what happens, until Bethesda says "Yes, there are horses" or "No, there are no horses", we can talk about horses all they long, but that still doesn't tell us if they're in the game or not.
IMO to make them a necessity (of sort) they should remove fast travel. I can see people crying over it already...
If they did that, I'd probably not play the game at all, in a game the size of the Elder Scrolls, I'd say some form of fast travel is essential, whether it's like in Oblivion, or travel services and teleportation spells isn't important, what's important is that it does its job. The game is simply too big to force the player to go everywhere in real time, especially with Skyrim's mountainous landscape, and I'll be pretty impressed if you manage to ride you're horse over the tallest mountains in the game.
And if you don't like it, don't use it, stop trying to ruin the game for everyone else. Oh, right, not using features you don't want to use is IMPOSSIBLE, having an optional feature you don't like automatically FORCES you to use it, because it's physically impossible to NOT click on one of the marker's on you're map or NOT click on the "travel" option when talking to the guy standing next to the silt strider. There's some sort of mysterious force that compells you to do so, I seem to have forgotten that important factor.
IMO if horses are to be in then fast travel should be out (please!) because otherwise they are little more than eye candy.
And IMO you should stop trying to ruin the game for other people and learn how to do the impossibly difficult task of not using features you don't want to use. Probably a lot more helpful than whining about features you don't like (And yes, when I see begging for the same thing at least three times in a thread that isn't even related to it, it IS whining, just because you add "IMO" before you're post doesn't change that.)
Also, Red Dead Redemption had fast travel, both as travel services and the ability to directly travel to various locations you've discovered from you're camp, I'd like to see you play that game and tell me the horses in it are "just eyecandy".
remove fast travel,you'll start liking horses really fast.
No, I'll just start hating the game really fast.