Seriously, how the heck do you do this? I can see my load order perfectly fine on OBMM. But am I supposed to type out each and every .esp in the list? I have quite a lot of mods. Is there any way to copy the load order or something?

OBMM stores you load order in a file called "plugins.txt". In W7 it is located in you appdata/roaming/Oblivion folder. There may be another way, but I don't know with OBMM. If you have Wrye Bash it's easy. I don't know if you have it though.

In OBMM, click on Import/Export and then View load order.