Weve already managed to refer maimed/blinded to possible hallucination and some other term I forget which MK replied to in some way as its good that you people are working together, so I assume thats what it means. So were looking for a witness locked in a myth by belief, whos potentially hallucinating or related. And knowing who this witness is will tell us who the amaranth is, or get us very close. So, maybe weve been looking for someone who fills in Nir's shoes? Someone who doesnt do much, but gets "killed"/maimed/wounded(hallucinating or however to put it) and leaves behind stuff of importance, maybe 12 of these things. Someone who witnessed the disappearance of an important Anu/Padomay couple. Although Im really tired and I admit I feel stupid for asking this: Is the witness the amaranth or its someone who was seen by the witness? Im lost in the speculation..
Also, forgot this.
The last thread ended with this (well, it's still open as of this writing, but post-limit yada yada), and I think that this is on the right track maybe.
At least the Witness is important. Just so I'm clear, because I haven't really been following this with my two jobs getting in the way, but is the Witness the Observer?
Because then I got stuff that I can go on with that.
EDIT: The person who fits "witness locked in myth by belief" could be Trinimac, Arkay, Godhead itself, or maybe
MnemnoliRANDOM IDEA THAT HAS NO REAL BASIS: Seht (and by extension Trinimac and pretty much all Enatiomorphic Observers). He witnessed the foul murder of Nerevar by Vehk.
Following this we can rule out that it's an Observer in an enatiomorph? Since Talos is important in the grand scheme, if we could figure out which of Ysmir/Hjalit/Arctus is the observer, that one could be the Amaranth.