The stick layout you were saying, the "legacy" layout, wont work all that well for Skyrim because of the fact the back peddal isnt an option anymore in this game. You either have to face and fight or turn and run away and the usual button mashing you would do with this layout of controller will make you hate this game. They make the controls how they are for a reason, not because some people wont think there are other better ways to reconfigure it, but because its the best layout suited to learn and adapt to the game they created.
And i play Call of Duty black Ops alot, my firend comes over and always changes my controller layout to tactical, from my favored DEFAULT layout. And every time he does it and i try to play, i die 5 times before i figure out, " OHH the B button is melee now! stupid me." (how useless is that? lol)
How would it not work?? it changes no buttons. It is only the thumbsticks and im only talking about this for the 360 console, not PC. Everything is normal, i just adjust to it better.
Tactical is what i play on.. thats a button layout, completely different than a thumbstick layout. You are talking about something completely different.