Price-drop-waiters will pay $30 or $40 for it. we all lost the game.
I paid $108 for it on release (which is cheap here), and am happy to say that it's still more than that for most people who go into a store to buy a copy today.
And the people who buy it a few months late and get it cheaper... Didn't have it on day one, didn't get to contribute to the release, don't get the pre-order DLC (at least not yet), and haven't been able to learn the joys of playing as early as I have.
And OP... I'm glad you appreciate what the game has done right, and I'm sorry the flaws in it have hit you as hard as they have. For myself, personally, the good FAR outweighs the bad, and the game is one of my favourites ever. It's a personal thing though, and I can see where the flaws are, and that for many people, those flaws will be enough to hold it back in their eyes.