Well, I completely disagree. Having pointless, random NPCs with no job, home or anything breaks immersion for me. Make them quickly and give them generic house interiors or whatever, I don't care, but they could still make many more unique ones. And I want them all to have a home. It would actually be very immersion breaking to have a city with 10 houses and 100 NPCs.
:blink: Hm? Are you sure you quoted the right post?
I agree with you, I stated pretty much the same thing you did in the other thread about generic NPCs. All I was saying in the post you quoted was that conversations between NPCs in Oblivion were god-awful. (IE: Random NPC 1: "Greetings, Imperial." Random NPC 2: "How are you today?" Random NPC 1: "Fantastic! Thanks for asking!" Random NPC 2: ".........HOORAY!" End conversation.)
Those types of NPC-NPC interactions are just terrible sounding and more annoying than immersive. I'd still love to see conversations between NPCs, but I want them done better in Skyrim.