» Fri Jun 03, 2011 7:55 am
Because the PC modding crowd sees a console editor as Crayon, and themselves as Da Vinci.
Mind you, I'd be unsurprised if the technical limitations killed any chance of a useful editor for it, but you have to look at it the other way around.
Basically, they don't see it as possible to compare with their level of tools, and it cheapens the view of what they do. Or something like that. It's an elitism thing. All artists do it.
Maybe I like crayons? Look at artists like Da Vinci... then look at Van Gough. Obviously there are artistic differences where one strove for realism and the other a more abstract approach. Maybe I like the challenge of building something beautiful with a lesser set of tools and components than i could use, but THAT is where I find the fun. The thing could be a slightly upgraded Far Cry 2 editor for all I care and I won't be sad. I just want that option.
Also look at the last couple COD games (I don't like to give props to it at all but I can use it to try to make a point). Which versions sold more? I'll give you guys 2 guesses. Hell I'll give you all a hint too: It wasn't the PC ones. Not by a long shot.
So where do you think Crytek and EA are going to make their money if the game is a success? And we ARE talking EA here, success to them is at least 5mil copies and that may be low balling it on my end. Now with the Money Grabbers that EA are why would you think they would want versions of the game to be crippled in such a way as to make the "potential future bank" (by selling DLC and such) practically nonexistent beyond maybe 3 months?
The 'map editor' would indeed just end up placing blocks on a random flat surface ala halo.
I just can't see crytek bothering. If you want real mod tools, just buy a PC, you'll get far more out of it. Also, unlike pissing around on consoles, you can actually get something worthwhile out of it. If you're amazing with forge, you may get a recon helmet, if you're amazing with sandbox 2, you get a career.
Legos are still fun, even as an advlt. The thing is I wouldn't mind it just be placing blocks as long as I get to place those blocks and can say, "Hey guys! Look at this! I made this little self contained world that we can **** around in!" Also why wouldn't they bother with making it? the only reason why that I can see is that the console versions would be so butchered beyond belief that it ends up a complete flop on both consoles. But EA are money whores and as far as I know Crytek likes to make good games so I doubt that will happen.
Just the fact that they are even trying to make the games on Consoles proves that Crytek cares about GAMERS, no matter their creed and backing.