On the list of "things I'm worried about," being able to look down in first person and see legs is pretty much near the dead bottom of my list. I couldn't care less.
Graphics nitpicks would never downgrade a score for me anyway, unless they are glaring. Trivial things to me like "too much bloom" or "can't see legs when in first person" I couldn't care less about.
Heck, I hate the "everything is brown and gray" trend in this generation of games (which thankfully it looks like Skyrim will avoid) but I wouldn't even downgrade a score over that boring (in my opinion) design.
Agreed!!! to deny a game a perfect score over if you can see you legs in FP view is just a total lack of focus on the important issues, and a little bit of an ego for thinking that just because its a big deal to you, you think everyone else is gunna think the same thing so you dumb down it's score (you score games on a basic relevent catogory of things that just about every game can be put under). If you can get at least 50 people to agree with you on this thread that it deserves a score bump over not seeing your legs then i might change my view, but i think your chances are very slim my friend.
But... i do think seeing parts of your body would be immersive and would also come together nicely with being able to see your shadow cast on the ground as im assuming FP view can do this time around( todd has said the whole world has dynamic lighting and shadows).