Using a Straight Razor against a Super Mutant, not fun. (It might be fun though)
Using a Super Sledge against a Viper Leader, now that's fun.
But overall, Melee is fun, and as I said before my Guns, Melee, Unarmed, Energy Weapons, and Explosives are all 100 and my STR is 10, so I can use any weapon without negative effects.
It is if you have the right build.. so is a rolling pin vs a deathclaw.
On a console version of the game little jokey things like these fights are one of the few ways to spice up combat ( good thing I'm on PC. )
Hey quick off topic question: How do you get all those skills to 100? I like always end up getting like 100 in two. Like does it take a certain SPECIAL or is it the way you distribute the skill points?
On a intelligence 5 - 6 build, you should have at least three at 100 by level 30.
Only if you spread your build around alot and don't focus at a few skills early on will you end up thinly spread out.
My 3 weapon skill build had 100 in each, and 90+ in sneak and 60+ survival by the end of the game with 5 in intelligence.