I've been trying to write a reply to this thread for pretty much the whole day, on and off. I can never come up with anything that makes any sense, so I'll just splurge:...
Wow! You really thought about this, I see! That's cool. I appreciate that, and judging from your work I would expect nothing less. :foodndrink:
I won't try to pose any counter-points, save one which I will get to momentarily. Let me just say this: before you decide that Twitter has nothing to offer, try looking for someone or something you'd actually find interesting. Surely, out of the millions of people/organizations that tweet, one of them holds something interesting to you. You're right about people tweeting about what they had for breakfast, or just replying as if it
were a chat system (which I emphatically declare once more that it is not)... that's not interesting, and I don't really care. Those get un-followed almost immediately.
But some really are legitimate and useful. Really. And it's not just to get a wider audience, though that is certainly the driving force for many. It is also to provide another means of getting information. NPR is an excellent example of that. Their primary audience is radio listeners. They also have a very interactive and informative website. But I am not always at a computer, nor somewhere I can listen to the radio, so when they started tweeting I was thrilled! I have a simple app on my Blackberry (UberTwitter in case anyone is interested), and with it I can stay informed almost anywhere. Further, it is in a quick blurb-like format so I get what I need in a quick and nicely presented format that's perfect for the small-ish screen.
I'm just saying... if you think that the mundane types are all that Twitter has to offer, you're really missing the point. (Not you personally... the editorial "you", if you will!)
OK, now the counter-point. I don't think it's a fair statement that people are already familiar with the current system. People show up here every day that are not familiar with the system. If one doesn't care about that, and only cares about the people they are already dealing with, then I guess you're right. But I don't think that's really the case. By and large, I think people here are generally helpful, and willing to help new people get familiar with the system (as long as they are not too annoying!) But I don't think it's fair to assume that everyone already knows where to go and what to do. That's my observation, anyway.
And actually, now that I think about it in these terms, when it comes to information storage and retrieval, the forum system ... well, it kinda svcks! Topics are not really discoverable unless you already know about them, and finding older information is nearly impossible (at the very least, it is incredibly inefficient). Google will give you better results than this forum's search feature. Don't get me wrong... for collaboration and sharing ideas, forums are awesome! But that's where it ends. That's why we have things like wikis, and CMSs, and yes, social media.
Now for the big back-pedal: you guys (oops, and gals) rock, and whether you want to use Twitter or not, you will continue to rock! At least AFAIC. Modders are, IMHO, pretty selfless people: all the frustration, blood sweat and tears that go into your mods gets you... what? A paycheck? A job? (well, maybe!)... you get the point. I truly appreciate the time you put into making things just right, and would not want anything I say to detract from that. You make the world a better place... Kumbayah, anyone?
Seriously, thank you for your thoughts. I genuinely appreciate the time it took to write. And hey, if Twitter is gone in a few years, this will really seem silly. I really don't think that will happen... even if Twitter itself goes away one day, the mold is set... this form of communication is here to stay, and I truly believe it's full potential is just now being discovered. Perhaps it will even be embraced here one day.
Thanks again,
veg