Since my thread about House and the Kings got a bit distracted by the Brotherhood of Steel, I figured I'd make a thread just for it.

Basically, I think opinions about the Brotherhood come down to two things:

A) Do you accept the Brotherhood's premise that technology is dangerous? (Remember the context of the game-nuclear war, FEV, etc...)

B ) Do you think the Brotherhood is going about their roles as protectors correctly? Could anyone really be trusted with that power? (Remember the context of the game, the BOS-NCR war, "I Could Make You Care", etc...)

Remember to keep things civil and not make things personal or take things personally. Its a fictional faction in a fictional world in a game where nobody is perfect. As for the poll, I tried to do as best I could predicting positions people might take but if you feel I left one out, I'd be happy to edit it.