I would say that i'm similar to the OP where I have big shoulders, semi-muscular build, and a slight tone to my body, but i'm not exactly a flabby person either. Personally I think i'm screwed when it comes to women and whoever said "There's someone out there for everyone" never met my sorry hide heh heh.
Sorry OP got me i'm in the same boat as you and would love to know some answers to this.
Do you come across as feeling sorry for yourself because of this? Major turnoff...