Well, remember, don't judge a book by its one-paragraph plot blurb. Though I can certainly understand the reaction; everyone freaked out hardcoe when the novels were first announced.
Heh, Lcyanthropic Nerevaer wrote this brilliant rant about how TES was dead, it had sold him out as writer, and that he was going to boycott the series forever. Calmed down a bit since?
That was quite a arant, wannit? However, I think I should explain: I didn't hear about the books by themsleves, I heard about them as an aside to "no new TES for a while." Not to mention that same day the girl I'd been wooing was making out with another dude, so give me some leeway. Also, I hadn't read any Keyes yet and didn't know that he's actually a very good writer.
I have surprisingly high hopes for this series to be honest. He's demonstrated his ability to write high fantasy, and to do it very well. To be perfectly honest, I'm quite surprised that they've managed to get him at all. :shrug: I don't usually expect an author who's been nominated for NINE Locus awards to write a video game novelisation...
Basically my current way of thinking.
A lot of the naysayers have some good points, but mostly points that can only be resolved by reading the full book once it's released which, whatever we say here, I'm dead sure almost all of us will do. I respect those people's opinions personally because at least until I read some of Keyes' other books I shared those reservations.
Of course, then there's the totally crazy group of people who won't be satisfied no matter how good or bad the book is because they don't care about content as much as who is or is not writing it.