» Fri Feb 18, 2011 9:37 pm
I think an interesting turn of events might be to focus on one single city, but recreate that city to actual scale. The city I live in is what would be considered a "small town" to most of the world (population 50k). It is roughly 64 square miles. That's a long walk from one end to the other (trust me, I've done it). But that kind of scale with all the buildings and people would be plenty of space for a game world. Think of 50,000 unique NPCs to interact with. Think of all the buildings to enter. Think of a real town with different architectural styles because some buildings were built 100 years ago, and some were built last week. And there are abandoned buildings with homeless people and alleys and muggers and town guards that just can't possibly be everywhere at once. There could be districts like how real cities have a Chinatown district, a waterfront, a bar district, government district, and so on. I don't need a whole State. One single city, done right, would be a refreshing change of pace.
EDIT: And before anyone says "Grand Theft Anything," keep in mind that I said 1: "to scale," and 2: "done right."