» Thu Oct 30, 2008 8:54 pm
Okay, so I was fairly happy with this patch. It fixes a lot of things that needed fixing (though not nearly all of them), adjusts balance pretty well in most cases. But I have one big exception to that, namely the HUGE nerfing of the Sniper Rifle. Rather than just complain about it, let me explain why in full detail:
My understanding is that the Sniper Rifle was rebalanced in order to make the Hunting Rifle not so blatantly useless by comparison, especially given how (relatively) easy it is to acquire either. Perfectly reasonable, totally understandable, and something I would agree should be addressed. The problem is that by simply nerfing the Sniper Rifle, the only thing that's changed is that now the Sniper Rifle is also (mostly) useless because other, better, scope-capable weapons still exist.
The Trail Carbine is a good example: it has the same damage rating as the Hunting Rifle, higher DPS than the (nerfed) Sniper Rifle, takes a scope, has a lower strength requirement, lower weight, lower AP cost (by more than half), has a perk which improves its damage (Cowboy), and to top it all off the ammo for it is cheaper and more abundant. The only advantage the Sniper Rifle has is that it can be silenced, and the Gobi Campaign variant doesn't have that advantage. And then when you compare the Hunting Rifle to that... yeah, still useless.
Now I will admit that the 62 damage the Sniper Rifle did previously was a LOT. It could have used a bit of adjustment. Unfortunately what was done was (in my opinion) too much. And adjusting the Sniper Rifle's damage doesn't do anything about the Hunting Rifle's continuing uselessness; increasing the damage that weapon did WOULD have fixed the issue.
Finally, I have a final thought of sorts, something a friend of mine pointed out to me while discussing this. In real-world terms, one of these is a $500 bolt-action rifle meant for hunting deer and the like, while the other is a $50,000 piece of military hardware; of COURSE one of them is going to be just plain better than the other.